To promote the use of art for raising awareness about the developing world
Notes on Kuna Culture
Disappearing Matriarchal Cultures of the World ... by Simon & Katerina
Diary notes from our stay on the Kuna Islands, Panama...
Walk to SanBlas Islands
Carti Subtupu Island
Men & Womens work
Observations during Sketching and Painting
The cruise ship
Trade Boat to Ustupu
Jungle Path Ustupo to Uala
Mountain Kuna village
The Sketch
Kunas in Panama city
El Llano Carti road:
The new road to the SanBlas islands was under construction. We asked a boy who was guarding a large Cat Digger if it would be possible to get a lift along the road in the morning.
“Yes, no problem, truck will be leaving at around 8 am.”
“Do you know the SanBlas islands, have you been there?” we inquired.
"I've been there a few times,” he said and hesitated before continuing.
“The SanBlas islands are like a prison, everyone knows what you’re doing and you’re not free. I was talking with some Kuna girls when an old man asks me to leave them alone. The girls had come to talk to me. Even for them it must be horrible. It is not a free place. They are small communities. I wasn’t trying to steal them away. I was just passing the time, because there is nothing really to do there. It is like a prison, I could never live there.
We asked him what Panamanians around El Llano think of Kuna people.
"We get along with them ok, but we don’t really like them because they are too different."
When will the road be finished?
"Grading of new El Llano Carti road for normal traffic is expected to take several years," he said "once finished it will be the only land route to the SanBlas islands.
hello
We camped in a lumpy field nearby.
Day 1: into Kuna Yara
In the morning the workers arrived and joked with us about jaguars in the mountains. They gave us a ride in a tipper lorry to the end of the road construction 8/10 km into the hills. From there we walked. At first the way was easy, we passed another team of road workers and a few basic houses before arriving at a lonely telephone box. After Katerina tried without success to phone the Czech Republic we continued. The track became narrower and very muddy, around us was thick jungle.
After an hour we passed a Spanish Lodge and came across a sign saying "Waterfall / Kuna Yara". We descended into the jungle in search of the waterfall. Three hours later we emerged again back on the track, very muddy and tired not having found the waterfall. We also lost one of our water bottles, which Katerina was convinced was stolen by howler monkeys.
Further down the track we met two people. The first was an unusually tall Kuna, (Kunas are supposed to be the second smallest people in the world, after the Pigmies of Central Africa) the second man was a westerner with briefcase.
They were going to the telephone box to call a taxi. The Kuna told us that they come from Nusagandi Lodge, which marks the entrance into Kuna Yara (Kuna territory). If we wanted we could stay the night. He would be returning in a few hours. We said ok because this was going to be the only house between here and the coast.
Two hours on we arrive at the lodge. It was a large wooden house with balcony and bunked rooms. The whole place was in a bad state of disrepair. We sheltered from the rain and washed cloths. When the Kuna returned he said 5 dollars each to stay.
Considering there was no running water toilet or shower we thought it to be a bit of a rip off. So we left to camp on a nearby hill. We lit a fire under a shelter of an old settlement and ate instant noodles. We had been warned that Kunas weren’t the most generous of people. Thunder, wind and rain continue for most of the night.
Day 2: Along the track
After walking for 3 hours we arrived at the edge of the mountains. Below us Jungle stretched out to the coast and small islands could be made out off shore. The view although stupendous was also a little depressing because it was obvious we would not reach the coast by night fall. Katerina said that she could not walk any further because her sandals were all muddy and wet. So I give her a pair of my thick socks to stop her feet slipping around so much and we continued.
We descended from the mountains to a small river where we washed and ate. The jungle here was hotter and took another gruelling 3 hours trek to a larger river. Here an old iron bridge hung disabled. The track had obviously once seen better days. The only way was now through the river, but the water luckily wasn’t too deep. Just before arriving at the river we had walked passed fields of maize and platano, the first signs of Kuna habitation. The sun was low and ten billion sand flies were swarming above our heads. We set camp as fast as possible, 3m from the waters edge on thick vegetation.
During the night we heard creatures splashing in water just outside our tent. Using a candle I tried to see what it was, we had no torch. Were Caiman in this river? I got my umbrella ready just encase they attacked the tent. Later during the night other squeaky noises came from behind and around the tent. Perhaps we had camped on their route to the river?
Day 3: The coast
Next morning at first light 5:30am Kunas arrived from down river in dugout canoes. Five canoes came in all with approximately 20 men. They talked aloud, hauled up their canoes and then washed in river. In this jungle setting they appeared like a wild tribe. One man came over towards me so I asked what they were up to.
“We are going to plant maize,” he said. He then washed maize kernels in a woven basket demonstrating that the ones that float are bad and he throws out.
“Are there Caiman here? Crocodile? How big?” I asked.
“Small,” he said, stretching out his arms then shrinks them to about half a metre. He also confirmed the squeaky noises we’d heard during the night as young Caiman.
“How long will you work?”
“We will come back at 9am. We can give you a lift to the islands in our canoes if you like?”
We declined there offer because we had planned to walk along the path all the way to the coast.
The men left. We made a sketch of the river and broken bridge, including where the men had been in their canoes. Katerina worked from inside her tent away from the million sand flies. I sprayed copious amounts of insect repellent on and waved my hat about while trying to paint. The insects were too ferocious to complete anything so we packed up at 10am. The men had not returned.
After walking for an hour we find a newly constructed hospital, void, however, of any amenities inside. A Kuna man sawing a piece of wood nearby said the Panamanian Government is paying for it and once the road gets here they will equip it. All the building material had arrived by boat.
He directed us onto the airstrip where a broad concrete runway leads to the beach. A few Kuna women and men lazed under a shelter. We had made it to the coast, but it wasn’t quite as idyllic as I’d imagined. The entire shore was littered with rubbish, plastic bottles, plastic bags cartons and paper. The prevailing wind was from the islands!
A Kuna man approached us and asked where we wanted to go. We pointed out to the islands.
“$1.75 per person to Carti Subtupu Island,” he said in an official voice.
We discover he is like a Kuna islands representative to meet tourists who arrive by plane, but we hadn’t arrived by plane so he wasn’t sure about us.
“Will the road be good for Carti Subtupu?” I asked him.
“Yes, but many people will come and it will influence the way of life here. I don’t know if it will be good or bad but there will be changes.”
“Are women stronger than men here?”
“We are an equal society. Each has their own work duties, we don’t tell each other what to do. The island chief Sahila is a man. Every day there is meetings in the main hall 1 for women 1 for men and sometimes mixed. We are equal and every person including children can have their say.”
Katerina washed her sandals then rested in an old dugout canoe. I made a sketch of the coast looking out to the islands, including of course the rubbish. The island representative returned and looked at my picture.
“Beautiful,” he said.
I pointed out the rubbish to him on my picture which I don’t think he recognised!
“Yes lots of rubbish,” he acknowledged. “It comes from the islands.”
He said no more to me and went to speak with Katerina who asked more questions about Kuna tradition.
The women making Molas under the shelter didn’t take much notice of us so we took a large dugout with outboard engine to Carti Subtupu Island.
back
Carti Subtupu Island
A small man named Thomas greeted us. He was responsible for looking after tourist visitors. Firstly we got briefly introduced to the Island chief Sahila who was very fat and had several women around him. Then we got shown the tourist dormitory which was behind the Medical Centre on the far west of the island $ 8 per person.
Our first impressions of life on the island
It seemed we had entered a very tight nit community not wholly friendly to outsiders. At first we were afraid to leave the dormitory. After an hour Thomas came and escorted us to the community run comedor to eat then gave us a brief tour of the island.
The Island was roughly 200m by 70m and is 1 of a group of 4 all within half a kilometre. Census year 2000 gave 970 pop, 121 families. The island was squashed full of houses, mostly made from wood with palm thatched roofs, a few houses were built from concrete. This island had no beach and rocks seemed to have been piled up in order to expand its size as much as possible. Sea depth around the island was approximately 2 to 3 metres.
A few men asked us if we wanted to go on a tour to other islands and the jungle. One of them was called Ernesto; he was quite desperate to gain some business, that’s why I remembered his name. He also wanted us to paint a new sign for him saying "Ernie’s Bar and Paradise Tours”, but it was on a metal sheet which we didn’t have the right paints for.
The women were nearly all dressed in traditional cloths and seemed quite shy and reserved. Men had lost their traditional cloths but were far more extravert, perhaps because they could speak better Spanish. Lots of kids were in the street going to or from school. Both boys and girls were inquisitive and spoke to us without indifference.
back
Men’s work Observations:
- Collecting fresh water from the river. A 2 hour round trip sailing or paddling in dugout canoe, Made anytime of day but mostly in mornings.
- Fishing with net and lines, often a day trip is made to get to desired location i.e. less inhabited islands and or deeper water. Some men specialise in diving for shells, crabs and lobsters which can also takes them most of the day.
- Trips to the mainland for cultivation of maize, platano, bananas, some mangos and papaya but hardly any vegetables. These trips could also be for collecting natural materials for building houses and canoes etc. Usually they went as an organised group and can we were told include women.
- Shops on the islands were mostly run by women but a few by men.
- Relaxing, men didn’t tend to drink excessively, maybe because it was prohibited to drink for much of the daytime. Many men, however, could be seen lazing around. The community idea of sharing the work load appeared to allow some people more time off than others?
- Some men smoked and others sometimes were drunk but of no trouble to anyone.
Women’s work observations:
- Women sit outside houses with babies and or stitching Molas. There also seemed to be quite a lot of gossiping and observing the action on the street. None of them, however, asked us directly who or where we were from. That information was left to the men to extract and then passed to the women.
- Sweeping the house, splashing water on the ground to make it damp, feeding babies, cooking for the family, looking after family finances, running the shops, making Molas, taking kids to kinder garden, gossiping, spying on other families and having fun with other women, dressing up in traditional cloths, asking us to buy Molas.
- Relaxing, women were rarely seen to be doing nothing; they either had material for making Molas on their laps or a baby or things for book keeping. The Molas, however, seems to be the most popular pastime? Women we saw weren’t drinking or smoking.
Exceptions in Men/women’s work observations:
- We saw a few men who were making Molas; they appeared more feminine than usual but were not seen to dress up in women’s cloths. Gays seemed to be accepted into society with out problem.
- Other men made jewellery for selling to women and tourists, they seemed normal.
- Men also cooked in cafes while women sat, took money and kept stock.
Island Politics:
Here men seemed to have more power. The island chief Sahila was a man and Tour guides were also all men.
back
Observations during Sketching and Painting
It proved difficult to make on location studies of women. Mainly because men and kids who were watching us would shout out to the women nearby which of them we were drawing. This caused the woman in question to either flee the scene or to cover herself up in her red head scarf. Hence many of them we drew had to be a mixture of several put together.
After shifting locations around the island we found the best spot to be near the kindergarten, where the women couldn’t leave their toddlers.
On the pier was also a good spot because people were always arriving from other islands unloading or loading up.
Some women seemed especially offended by us. Perhaps because usually they charge tourists for photos and maybe thought that we were somehow getting something for nothing? I asked a Teacher who was Panamanian about this. He said that they are proud people and always want to look good, but he didn’t think they would have been offended by painting. Maybe they would be happy to sit for you if you pay them. I told him that as soon as they sit in an organised way the whole point of us coming to the island to see them normally would be lost, but maybe he did have a point.
Men on the other hand were easier subjects. Younger men sometimes argued over being drawn while the older men tended to move away quickly. At the pier men hung around the community comedor, this was the best place I found.
Kids always formed crowds around us often obscuring the view, pushing, stepping or falling onto the picture.
Our reception to the Island in the short period we were there was not affected greatly by the fact that we were doing pictures. Thomas came a few times in the evenings to collect money or empty the toilet rubbish into the sea! On these visits we showed him our latest paintings.
He asked why we were doing them; we told him it was for an exhibition of Matriarchal cultures from around the world. He then asked if we have our own museum. At first I found this answer amusing but then realised this is usually how museums begin.
The same question by other people on the street weren’t so satisfied by our explanation. They wanted to know who much we sell them for. We said that they would not be for sale, because we didn’t want them to ask us for money.
After this they seemed less impressed by the picture. Prices for Molas were then boasted about $10 to $20 each, and one woman said she had sold a Mola for $100.
Men often said that Kunas have their own artists as well and that they are not women but men. They said this with obvious pride. Sadly Carti Subtupu didn’t have any of these artists. The only man here doing pictures was the man who owns the island museum.
One man Museum + History of Gender in Kuna society:
The man who runs the museum was also a budding artist. His pictures were illustrations of the history and legends of the Kuna culture. His style was inspired by western sci-fi comic books, which made for dramatic representations of old Kuna stories. I thought, however, it suited his subjects which included gods with animal heads and shooting stars that attack people.
Before western religion arrived here there were 2 primary Gods, 1 male 1 female to teach either sex there role in society. So equality seemed to be high on the agenda even in antiquity, although, celebrations for the female sex appear throughout history to be cherished more than that of the male?
back
The cruise ship:
This year only 2 cruise ships had come so everyone was making a special effort for this one. Women were visually extra busy stitching up Molas and those who didn’t usually wear traditional clothing started getting use to wearing them again.
Thomas was responsible for cleaning up the dock area. A large amount of rubbish was washing up and down.
It doesn’t look good does it, I said, Thomas told me that he has to make a good impression because only a few cruise ships had come this year.
I agreed that something had to be done and looked down at the rubbish washing up and down around the pier. It looked like a thick minestrone soup. There were jokes that Katerina and I should clean it up in return for free food and accommodation. Thomas spent most of the day pacing around looking down at the rubbish.
“Why don’t you burn the paper rubbish and recycle the beer cans instead of throwing everything in the sea?” we said.
“We have talked about a dump on the mainland for rubbish yes.”
It appeared to me the Kunas gained some satisfaction from throwing the rubbish into the sea. For example when our toilet rubbish bin was full I informed Thomas. He came to sort it out, but to my horror just emptied the contents of the bin into the sea! So why put a bin there in the first place I thought.
Eventually one of the Lobster divers was employed to clean up the pier. He dived for the cans of beer, plastic bags and paper cartons which he loaded into his dugout canoe and took it somewhere else? Afterwards it looked mildly better, but this was really only a token gesture because the other 99.9 % of the island was still caked in rubbish and toilet paper. Thomas, however, seemed happy with the effort.
What the women did when the cruise came:
At 5am all the women were busy hanging up Molas from their houses. The island was transformed into a maze of brightly coloured paths. Thousands of Molas were on display, small, large, all types, from geometric designs to toucans to turtles. Other items included T-shirts with Mola designs, clay pots and arm bands. Women were notably jollier which I found amusing. Some of them had also adopted a new appearance entirely in order to please the cruise visitor. Many had clay pipes sticking out of there mouths, not lit. Others sported small green budgerigars on the shoulder or an iguana on the head. And finally the women who were getting use to wearing traditional cloths again sat there comfortably like it was their second skin.
Women were hardened sellers.
What the men did when the cruise came:
Men wore the same old American style cap and clothes, but suddenly had something to sell. They had produced small squared and painted balsa wood boats with mast and sail. No relation to the indigenous canoes? These items I was told were thought up recently as competition for the women’s Molas. $10 for Molas, $1 for boats, not much competition really.
One man I was trying to draw held up his boats in front of his face so I couldn’t see him. Then unexpectedly a tourist came along and bought it. He then got up and left. A while later he returned with a beer in his hand and a smile on his face. Maybe the Molas pay for luxuries like TV’s and sound systems while boats are just for beers.
What the kids did when the cruise came:
Kids sold drawings, but sadly from our creative perspective most were copied from school text books, pictures of animals and boats. Only a few had their own drawings, we purchased some examples for 50 cents. Many kids had plagued cruise visitors for $1 to take a photo of them. And as the cruise visitors were cueing to leave the island a frenzy of women and children swarmed around them pleading them for money and photos. It seemed all a little to desperate and appeared to make the cruise visitors want to leave even more.
Cruise visitors:
The Cruise visitors were mainly North American who looked freshly showered in white summer cottons, most were over 40. The cruise liner was large white and shiny and parked it’s self a short distance from the islands. It resembled a giant state of the art washing machine floating on its side. The cruise was carrying 1500 passengers, most of whom came to the island, roughly doubling the population for half a day.
Post Cruise:
By far the most profit making commodity for sale was the Mola and reports afterwards suggested a successful day was had by many. The following day everyone was visibly happier, some women even smiled at us. Posters went up marking dates for shopping trips to Panama City. More men that usual were drinking at the community shop near the pier.
Luxuries on Carti Subtupu:
The idea of a community where everyone chips in and there is no need for money seemed to be something of the past here. There was definitely competition to whom could sell the most.
Individual Kuna families are permitted to open their own shops on the island selling bread, tined food, toilet paper etc. We were told there was some competition between them to get rich.
Most houses had TV’s, radios, and beds instead of the traditional hammock. A community generator was started up each evening for electricity. Use of electricity costs $3 per month per house, not many houses went without.
back
Trade Boat to Ustupu:
It was a last minute decision for us to take this 2 day boat trip. The plan was to see in all the islands down to Ustupu. Then to walk over the mountains back to the Pan American highway passing two Mountain Kuna villages on route.
Islands:
List of islands the boat stopped at to trade, plus our grades of sophistication.
Carti Subtupu 3 , Punta Playa 2 , Marmattupu 2 , Río Azúcar 4 , Corazón de Jesús 6 , Nargana 5 , Punto Silanega 3 , Niatupu 2 , Playón Grande (coastal settlement) 2 , Playón Chico (sleep) 3 , SanIgnacio de Tupile 3 , Aligandi 4 , Achutupu 3 , Mamitupu 3 , Ustupu ( stay 2 nights ) 4 .
Key:
1 = Basic natural island with a couple of houses;
3 = Mainly traditional houses some concrete, with electricity;
5 = Half and half concrete and traditional houses, electricity, plus not many women in traditional cloths.
Note: Women were dressed in traditional cloths in all the islands apart from Nargana and Corazon de Jesus. Many of the islands unlike Carti Subtupu also had nice beaches. The boat was from Ustupu island so all the workers on board were from there too.
|